By Rabbi Michael Skobac
“And Yosef said to his brothers: I am Yosef. Is my father still alive? And his brothers were not able to answer him for they were shocked at his presence”
Throughout this dramatic episode, Yosef has relatedly asked about his father’s welfare and if he’s still alive (see 43:7). Just prior to revealing himself to his brothers, Yosef asked once more if his father is still alive, and the brothers confirm that he is (43:27-28). Yosef has been with his brothers the entire time since they assured him that their father was still alive, so why does he now ask them again?
Another perplexing matter here is the comment of the Midrash on the brothers’ shock after Yosef’s self-revelation. “Woe to us for the day of judgement, woe to us for the day of rebuke!” Where do we see rebuke in Yosef’s words?
The Bais HaLevi explains that the brother’s claim all along has been that if Benjamin would not be freed, it would break Jacob’s heart and kill him. Yosef didn’t need to find out now if Jacob was still alive – that was already discussed. His question was meant as a rebuke. If you are so concerned about our father’s well-being, why weren’t you apprehensive about his welfare when you sold me? The brothers had no legitimate response to this inconsistency.
Brought By Rabbi Michael Skobac
Rabbi Michael Skobac had been involved with Jews for Judaism (Canada) since 1989 and currently serves as its Director of Education and Counselling. He is a leading authority on missionaries, cults and issues relating to Jewish continuity and Jewish spirituality. Rabbi Skobac's publications include Missionary Impossible; Counter-Missionary Survival Guide; The DaVinci Code: A Jewish Perspetive; and Intermarriage: Is There Ligth at teh End of the Tunnel?
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.
NoahideAcademy.org's copyright policy.
Republished by Angelique Sijbolts with permission for the Noahide Academy.